Coupons
Help
  • FAQ
    browse most common questions
  • Live Chat
    talk with our online service
  • Email
    contact your dedicated sales:

Why Does Immersion Tin Cause Solder Mask Peeling?

Author : Hackett Wang | PCB Manufacturing Engineering & Technical Content Specialist

November 04, 2026


Immersion tin is widely used as a PCB surface finish, but solder mask peeling, edge whitening, and localized mask erosion can occur when the solder mask, copper pretreatment, development process, and immersion-tin chemistry are not well matched. A key chemical component in many immersion-tin solutions is thiourea. Because thiourea can be aggressive toward certain solder mask formulations, it may attack the mask surface and edges, particularly when the mask has insufficient adhesion or has not been fully cured.

 

Main Causes of Solder Mask Peeling on Immersion-Tin PCBs

Incomplete Solder Mask Curing

If the solder mask is not fully cured, its cross-linking density remains insufficient. The coating may retain a structure that behaves somewhat like a sponge, allowing the immersion-tin solution to be absorbed into the mask or to penetrate through weak areas at the coating edge. Once the chemical solution enters these regions, it can weaken the bond between the solder mask and copper surface.

This condition may initially appear as slight whitening around the mask edge. With continued chemical exposure, the affected area can expand, eventually producing lifting, blistering, or complete peeling. Insufficient curing can result from an incorrect baking temperature, inadequate curing time, insufficient curing energy, or nonuniform heating across the panel.

In addition to reducing chemical resistance, under-curing also lowers the mechanical strength of the PCB solder mask. A coating that appears acceptable during visual inspection may still fail when exposed to the immersion-tin bath, rinsing, drying, and subsequent thermal stress. The curing process must therefore be evaluated together with the solder mask material and the chemical process window.

Solder Mask Curing

Poor Copper Pretreatment and Insufficient Adhesion

The condition of the copper surface directly affects solder mask adhesion. If the copper is not properly cleaned and roughened before solder mask application, the coating may have insufficient mechanical anchoring. After immersion tin, the weak interface is more likely to be attacked or lifted by the chemical solution.

A simple tape test can provide an initial indication of adhesion. If the copper surface remains unusually bright after the tape test, the solder mask may not have bonded adequately to the copper. This does not replace a complete process evaluation, but it can help identify a weak pretreatment condition.

Pumice scrubbing can produce a suitable and relatively uniform copper surface roughness for solder mask adhesion. By contrast, boards treated only by certain sandblasting processes may be more susceptible to erosion after immersion tin. The result depends on the actual roughness profile, cleaning condition, process uniformity, and compatibility between the treated copper and the solder mask. Pretreatment should therefore be assessed by observing both adhesion and the condition of fine features after surface finishing.

Developer Undercut at the Solder Mask Edge

Overdevelopment or an unsuitable development condition can cause lateral erosion of the solder mask image. This phenomenon, commonly called undercut, removes material beneath the nominal edge of the mask and creates a small overhanging structure or "ledge." The top of the mask may look properly defined, while the lower edge is already weakened.

During immersion tin processing, the solution can collect in this recessed region. Continued exposure allows the chemistry to attack the weakened edge from the side and underneath. Peeling may then begin at the undercut location and progress inward beneath the solder mask.

Undercut can be related to developer concentration, spray pressure, developing speed, temperature, exposure conditions, or insufficiently controlled imaging parameters. The defect is particularly critical around narrow solder mask bridges and densely spaced SMD pads, where only a small amount of remaining mask material separates adjacent copper features.

Developer Undercut

Chemical Attack and Insufficient Design Margin

Thiourea and other components in the immersion-tin solution can attack the resin system of the solder mask. The risk increases when the mask is under-cured, poorly adhered, or already weakened by development undercut. Chemical residue left on or beneath the solder mask can also become a long-term reliability concern if rinsing and drying are inadequate.

Narrow solder mask bridges between closely spaced SMD pads are especially vulnerable. If the bridge width is too small, chemical attack can remove the remaining mask completely. A design that passes the imaging process may therefore fail during surface finishing because the available mask margin is insufficient for the chemical exposure.

As a practical design check, verify that the solder mask bridge width is greater than 0.125 mm (5 mil), and confirm that the spacing between an SMD pad and a via is not excessively small. The 0.125 mm value should be treated as the design criterion for the stated case, not as a universal requirement for every PCB process. The actual limit depends on the solder mask material, imaging capability, board structure, and immersion-tin chemistry.

 

How to Investigate and Correct the Problem

Process and Design Evaluation

  1. Confirm the design rules. Check the solder mask bridge width between SMD pads and review the clearance between pads and vias. Pay particular attention to narrow mask webs and areas where the mask edge is exposed to chemical flow from multiple directions.
  2. Evaluate copper pretreatment. Confirm whether pumice scrubbing or another controlled roughening process is being used. Check the surface condition after treatment and compare the results across the panel rather than evaluating only one location.
  3. Verify the curing process. Review the solder mask baking temperature, curing time, and available curing energy. Confirm that the process provides complete curing across the full panel and that the actual condition is compatible with the selected ink.
  4. Check development parameters. Investigate developer concentration, spray condition, temperature, and conveying speed. The objective is to eliminate excessive lateral erosion while maintaining complete removal of uncured mask from the intended openings.
  5. Confirm chemical compatibility. Work with the immersion-tin chemistry supplier and solder mask supplier to determine whether the process combination has excessive chemical aggressiveness. The evaluation should include the actual mask formulation, curing condition, bath condition, and exposure time.

Verification Testing

Several tests can help distinguish insufficient adhesion, under-curing, development undercut, and direct chemical attack.

  1. Soldering thermal-stress test. Use the applicable IPC-TM-650 method to simulate soldering-related high-temperature stress and inspect the board for blistering, lifting, or peeling. This test helps reveal weaknesses that may not be visible at room temperature.
  2. Solvent wipe test. Use a lint-free cloth moistened with immersion-tin bath solution to wipe the cured solder mask surface. Observe whether the coating discolors, softens, becomes tacky, or loses surface material. This test is useful for identifying a mask that is chemically vulnerable or insufficiently cured.
  3. Microscopic and metallographic analysis. Section an affected area and examine the cross-section under a microscope. The analysis can show whether the failure began as a sidewall undercut, an interface adhesion defect, a void beneath the mask, or chemical attack through the mask edge.

The failure location is also informative. Peeling concentrated at mask corners or narrow bridges may indicate insufficient design margin or undercut. Peeling distributed across broad areas may point more strongly to curing, adhesion, or chemical compatibility. A cross-sectional comparison between good and defective regions can help separate process variation from a design limitation.

 

Improving Solder Mask Adhesion Without Super-Roughening

When a PCB cannot use a super-roughening process, solder mask adhesion can still be improved through controlled chemical or physical surface treatment. Each option has advantages and limitations, particularly for fine-line and fine-pitch products.

Chemical Surface Roughening

A mild micro-etch process can create chemical roughness on the copper surface before solder mask application. The roughened surface provides additional area and microscopic anchoring points for the coating while allowing the existing production line to be used.

The main advantage is process compatibility and relatively straightforward integration. However, the etchant must be tightly controlled. On fine traces, excessive etching can reduce conductor width, increase the risk of line loss, or affect the spacing between adjacent features. The process should therefore be evaluated using the actual line width, line spacing, copper thickness, and solder mask pattern.

Chemical roughening is a direct alternative to traditional roughening in applications where a more aggressive mechanical treatment is undesirable. Its practical performance depends on uniform control of etch rate, surface cleanliness, and the time between treatment and solder mask coating.

Physical and High-Energy Surface Treatment

Plasma treatment is another option. It can significantly improve surface activity and promote better interaction between the copper surface and solder mask. Its limitation is that the activation effect is time-dependent. According to the stated process condition, coating should be completed within 4 hours after treatment to preserve the benefit of activation.

Mechanical brushing with abrasive brush wheels is also possible. This method is generally economical and can provide useful surface preparation for conventional boards. Its limitations are process uniformity and the possibility of damaging fine traces or reducing the dimensional margin of delicate features. It is therefore more suitable for boards with relatively large line widths and spacings than for fine-line products.

Regardless of the selected treatment, surface preparation should be validated together with solder mask curing, development, and immersion-tin exposure. Improving only one step may not solve the failure if another step continues to create a weak interface or an undercut edge. Reliable performance requires sufficient mask design margin, a properly roughened and clean copper surface, complete curing, controlled development, and verified compatibility with the immersion-tin chemistry.

Hackett Wang | PCB Manufacturing Engineering & Technical Content Specialist Hackett Wang | PCB Manufacturing Engineering & Technical Content Specialist

Hackett Wang is a PCB industry professional at AIVON with experience in customer support, pre-production engineering review, customer quality, and technical content. He focuses on the point where design files meet factory process and writes from real order issues rather than textbook rules. At AIVON, he reviews and develops content on manufacturability and production practice, helping engineers prepare files so a design can enter production with fewer delays.

Related Tags


2026 AIVON.COM All Rights Reserved
Intellectual Property Rights | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Refund Policy